Special Education Settlements: What Parents Need to Know — And Why They’re Rising

Last year, New York City public schools spent nearly $400 million on special education settlements — a 31% jump from the year before. These settlement costs covered tuition reimbursements, private therapies, and attorney fees, often because parents had to fight to get the services their children were legally entitled to. And it’s not just a New York story. Across the U.S., public schools are spending hundreds of millions each year on special education settlements, with the totals climbing year after year.

Yellow scales balance books and a gavel with money on a blue background, symbolizing justice and education.

The rise is part of a broader national trend that shows no sign of slowing, especially with uncertainty around how the U.S. Department of Education will monitor IDEA compliance going forward. Many experts warn that without significant improvements in service delivery and oversight, these disputes — and the costly settlements that follow — are likely to become even more frequent, leaving both families and districts navigating a high-stakes, high-cost process.

What Special Education Settlements Really Are

A special education settlement is an agreement between a family and a school district to resolve a dispute without going to a full legal hearing. These disputes often begin with a due process complaint or mediation request when a parent believes the district isn’t providing the services outlined in their child’s IEP. Most special education settlements cover:

• Private school tuition when a district can’t meet a student’s needs

• Therapies and services outside of school (speech, OT, counseling)

• Independent evaluations from specialists

• Attorney fees for parents who prevail or settle on favorable terms

While special education settlements can be a lifeline for families, they happen after a child has gone without the right support — sometimes for months or years. The academic and emotional cost to the student can far outweigh the settlement amount.

Why Special Education Settlements Keep Happening

The rise in special education settlements isn’t random. Several systemic issues drive this pattern:

• Chronic underfunding of special education programs

• Persistent staffing shortages that delay or interrupt services

• Missed deadlines for evaluations or IEP meetings

• Parents with knowledge, resources, or advocacy support pushing cases forward

• Districts choosing to settle quickly to avoid even larger payouts after a hearing

These issues create a cycle: services are delayed or denied, parents file complaints, districts agree to special education settlements, and resources are diverted from proactive support to reactive payouts.

The National Trend in Special Education Settlements

The scale of the problem is growing. In states like California, Pennsylvania, and New York, districts have reported multi-million-dollar increases in special education settlement costs in just a few years. New York City’s settlement spending has increased tenfold over the past decade. This shift reflects a broader national trend — families are more aware of their rights, more willing to challenge inadequate services, and often successful in securing outside support through legal channels.

What This Means for Parents

Special education settlements prove that parents can get results when they have strong evidence and persistence. But the process is slow, stressful, and often expensive. The better path is to address problems early, before they escalate to a legal dispute.

Steps to Avoid a Long Fight:

• Document everything — keep service logs, IEPs, progress reports, and communication with the school.

• Follow up quickly when services aren’t delivered as promised.

• Know your rights under IDEA and your state’s laws — and be ready to cite them.

• Ask for meetings early when you notice issues, rather than waiting until the annual review.

How to Get Ahead of a Dispute

Highlighter was built to help families prevent disputes from turning into costly special education settlements:

• Review your child’s IEP and progress reports for gaps

• Keep all records and notes in one secure place

• Flag missing services or unmet goals early

• Use guided advocacy steps to request fixes before problems escalate

The Bottom Line

Families shouldn’t have to go to court to get their child the education they deserve. But with special education settlements on the rise and oversight uncertainty ahead, the safest move is to be proactive. By catching problems early and knowing exactly what to ask for, you can save months of frustration — and help ensure resources go where they belong: into your child’s learning, not into a legal settlement.

Get Help

Highlighter gives parents the tools to catch and address issues before they turn into costly, time-consuming special education settlements. By organizing IEPs, service logs, and progress reports in one secure place, Highlighter makes it easy to spot gaps, missed services, or unmet goals early. Our AI-powered guidance helps you understand your child’s rights, prepare clear requests for the school, and document everything you need to strengthen your case — whether that’s to resolve problems quickly or to be ready if a dispute does escalate.

Try Highlighter for Free